The Ink Blog - Printer and Cartridge News and Reviews

March 2010


Did William Hewlett and David Packer really know what they were starting all those years ago? HP’s done some many great things, but let’s focus on what they’ve done with printers (that’s what we talk about here, right?).

HP introduced us to inkjet and laser printers back in 1984. Since that time they have pretty much dominated the market with the size and selection of their machines and printer ink. HP continues to release a large number of new printer models each year. They also release several new sets of inkjet and laser toner cartridges each year.

But, just because HP is the biggest doesn’t mean they are the best.

HP has been know for releasing two cartridges for each inkjet printer (a black cartridge and a color cartridge) they make. Over the years, the idea of individual printer cartridges for each color of ink a printer uses has grown in popularity. HP has been slow to adopt this idea, but in 2005 they introduced their first black and color set. Since then they have been more apt to do the same.

At the same time they’ve been slowly adopting the individual color cartridges, HP has also been decreasing the amount of ink in their cartridges. Previous lines of printer cartridges held anywhere from 20-40 ml of ink. Their newest cartridges hold as little as 5 ml in some cases.

Given this trend, you you must really consider the long term costs of operating an HP printer before buying.

What do you think of HP printers? Are they your favorite? Take a minute and let me know. Thanks!

This one surprised me when I saw it. Someone is suing Lexmark for a change!

Lexmark is usually the one bringing lawsuits against companies that produce remanufactured cartridges for Lexmark printers, or companies that produce components that to in to remanufactured or compatible cartridges that replace Lexmark brand cartridges. The last big case Lexmark was involved in was 2003, when they brought a case against Static Control Components.

The base for the case was the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DCMA). This act was created to limit Internet piracy, but savvy lawyers found a way to test the boundaries of the act in other realms. Lexmark’s lawyers were part of that savvy bunch. Lexmark claimed that Static Control violated the DMCA by selling its Smartek chips to companies that refill toner cartridges and undercut Lexmark’s prices. According to Lexmark, the DCMA was violated because Smartek chip mimiced the authentication sequence used by Lexmark chips and unlawfully tricked printers into accepting an aftermarket cartridge.

So, in a turn of events, on February 22, 2010, Advanced Cartridge Technologies filed suit against Lexmark, claiming infringement on three of its patents. They claim that Lexmark knowingly and intentionally infringed their patents, and is also guilty of falsely marking its products with patent numbers.

What’s your opinion of these lawsuits? Take a minute and let me know. Thanks!

Last week was a quiet week here at the Ink Blog. I wish I could say I was away on vacation somewhere, but that was not the case. I was actually working in our warehouse. A jack of all trades I guess. Anyway, some help was needed to I jumped in. Interesting week. Definitely very different than sitting here in front of a computer typing.

Okay, back to the topic. This is a question we hear quite often. As customers gather information to make an informed purchasing decision, they almost always want to know how many times they can refill their ink cartridge. Refill in this case means using a refill kit or a refill service.

Unfortunately, there is no definite answer for this. The best we can give is an average. So, on average your printer ink cartridge can be refilled 3-4 times (and still print). In some cases you won’t be able to use your refilled cartridge at all, in other cases  you’ll be able to refill and reuse upwards of 10 times. Why so much variance?

The variance is caused by the cartridge’s print head, that shiny copper colored strip on the bottom of the cartridge. The print head facilitates communication between the printer and the cartridge. A damaged print head means no printing! Even a small scratch will cause your printer to be unable to recognize your refilled cartridge. If you think back to when you originally purchased your cartridge you should remember that the print head was covered (typically with tape) and had instructions that you should never touch it. Even finger prints on the print head could cause cartridge failure.

There are other parts of the cartridge that will wear out over time, but none cause as many failures as the print head.

Another factor that will determine the success or failure of a refilled printer cartridge is how often you used it, while it still had ink in it. The less often you use a cartridge, the more likely it is to fail when refilled. Ink dries inside the printer nozzles and impedes the amount of ink that can flow out of the cartridge. Once the clogging process starts, each successive print will cause more clogging.

So, to increase the odds of having your refilled cartridge successfully print, remember to treat the print head with the utmost care and to use your printer cartridges on a regular basis.

Do you have any cartridge refilling tips you would like to share? Take a minute to let me know. Thanks!

The days of dropping 300 bones on an all-in-one printer are fading away, while $150 devices like the Canon Pixma MP560 are quickly taking their place on retail shelves. The MP560 looks great and offers useful features like an auto-document feeder and a bright 2-inch LCD display, but it can’t keep up with other multifunction printers like the Epson WorkForce 310 and Lexmark’s Impact S305. Canon technically gives you more features, but we suspect that the sub-$150 market is more invested in print quality and speed. That leads us to recommend the Lexmark Impact S305 instead, which gives you higher quality pictures and prints documents in half the time for $50 less than the Canon Pixma MP560. (Source: CNET)

If you own this printer, let me know what you think about it. Thanks!

— CNET Rating: 3.5 Stars —

The good: Intuitive scroll wheel; large 2-inch LCD for photo viewing; wireless; auto-duplexer included; dual paper trays.

The bad: Mediocre print speeds; competition offers better image quality for less.

The bottom line: The Canon Pixma MP560 multifunction printer and its flashy 2-inch LCD screen and auto-document feeder may seem appealing at first, but the average consumer will find that Lexmark’s Impact S305 offers faster performance and higher quality results for $50 less. (Read the full CNET review)

— PCWORLD Rating: 3.5 Stars  —

Pros: Very nice photo quality; Automatic duplexing and roomy paper trays; Fast scanning speeds

Cons: Mediocre print speeds

Bottom Line: For a reasonable price, you get automatic duplexing and dual 150-sheet input trays, but the trade-off is mediocre print speed.

— Consumer Ratings: 4 Stars —

A positive comment from Amazon.com:

Nice printer, nice scanner, great for novice users

This printer was purchased as a birthday present for my mother, who has been hampered by a Windows Vista computer and a malfunctioning HP Printer (it worked great with XP…). We purchased the Canon PIXMA MP560 printer for $85 (free shipping) on Amazon, and comparing the price to other retailers online (and the retail price), it was no contest.

This printer has some features that you may already know of via the product description page, but I’d like to elaborate on some of these features.
Thoughts out of the box:
-The MP560 has a folding LCD screen that covers the function buttons. The screen is not too large, but it does seem to have large enough text (and a simple GUI) to work well for novice printer users. There are not too many buttons, and they’re large, well-marked, and simple enough for anyone to recognize.
-The printer has a lower paper tray (for regular inkjet/copier paper) and an upper vertical tray (for thicker photo paper and other things). The vertical tray has an automatic two-sided width adjustment/alignment, so any size paper is aligned to the proper position every time (and the thickness is adjustable from maximum printing width of the printer, down to only an inch or so).
-The basic instruction manual is printed on paper, and easily guided me through the process of installation of the print head/ink, paper, software, and wireless network capability. This guide has simple words and illustrations, though it does not include every detail of the printer’s operations (the more complex instruction/user manual is electronic, and is installed with the printer software). There is a Network Troubleshooting guide, as well, that seems to be rather detailed (though unnecessary in my case). The printer comes with a sample pack of 4″x6″ photo paper, which we immediately tested (and it passed the test with flying colors). There’s other throw-away junk included, but nothing that surprising.
-The printer is clearly labeled so as to make it simple to place cartridges in the right location, once the print head is installed.
-The fact that the MP560 has multiple single-color ink cartridges may seem expensive at first, but with tri-color cartridge printers, we would always seem to run out of a single color much faster than other colors… so we were wasting a good amount of ink each and every time we replaced a cartridge. This printer seems to have ink cartridges that would be easier to refill than some other cartridges, as well.

After powering it on:
-It was EFFORTLESS to set up the MP560 on our wireless network. It quickly detected the network (our router is on another floor in the house, on the other side of the house), and it still had a good quality signal, and it only took a few minutes (and only a couple pushes of a button… plus entering our internet security key) before the printer was connected. There is a rotating pad (similar to an IPod) on the printer that lets you select any security codes you may have (and navigate through the GUI)… so it may take awhile if one has an alphanumeric password, but it was rather quick for a numeric 8-key code. Heck, my mom is not too familiar with computers, and I have no doubts that she could have set up this printer with the network.
-The printer comes with easy to use software (again, in Vista), though it does take a few minutes for the software to install itself on a PC. The basic instruction manual makes it rather easy to install everything, whether using Windows or Mac. Once installed, the printer is rather effortlessly found (remember to have attached the printer to the wireless network), and before you know it, you’re ready to print.
-The printer has a laser ink level meter for every cartridge, and it can be displayed on the computer and on the 2″ LCD screen on the printer (actually, pressing one button on the “Home” screen will allow you to see each ink level). So far, it does not appear as if this printer over-uses ink… in fact, printing on glossy photo paper seems to suggest there’s less “gunk” on the paper than some other printers, perhaps due to the finer ink jets this printer allegedly uses.

Using the printer for the first time:
-The printer and software actually WORK WELL with Windows Vista!
-The printer does take a few seconds to warm up, but after the first print job, it seems to be much faster.
-The MP560 didn’t have a single problem feeding thicker photo paper.
-The quality of printed pictures is very good, showing very tight pixels even on plain paper. Photo paper shows an excellent picture quality, and the software included with the printer makes it effortless to print photos with certain photo papers… no need to change printer settings manually.
-The scanner/copier seems to produce quality pictures, although this isn’t the fastest, nor the quietest, copier I’ve seen in a multi-use printer.
-The Duplex printing feature is a great thing to have in a lower-cost home printer, as few documents are of an official, legal nature, hence there’s no need for one-sided printing. It gets to be inconvenient to flip the pages by hand each and every time one wants to print on both sides of a piece of paper, so it is great to find a lower-cost printer that has this feature. This printer does not print internally, it prints on one side and extracts the page, then gathers the page back inside the printer and prints on the other side, so I don’t know how well Duplex printing would work on thicker media such as fabrics.

All in all, this is a great printer so far. It beats anything I’ve ever owned, in terms of print quality and functionality, and I’d say it’s a pretty good value to boot. Mom is certainly happy about this printer, and she’s going to test it with some of her crafts… let’s see how it stands up to the test of time when she puts it to use.

A negative comment from Amazon.com:

Are you Kidding Me?

It’s no wonder Canon took so long to come up with wireless printers–they had no idea of what they’re doing. I got this MX860 the other night and there are about 60 pages on how to setup one’s network. Apparently, one can not setup the network from the printer and printer screen, as they could with normal printers like Brother, HP, etc.
You have to start a USB connection and run an install program that runs as slow as dirt to run wireless on this printer. This is like starting a jet by pulling it by horses. It baffles the imagination that Canon could make this so convoluted and over-complicated. In addition to that Canon fills up your computer with garbage.
It loads up about five programs into your startup tray, which bogs down your computer, and really serves no purpose at all.
No thanks! This baby is shipping back and I’ll look at a company that knows how to make a printer like Brother or Epson. (Read all Amazon.com user reviews)

« Previous Page